John Tiburzi on Sayville Market

Sayville in August: 12 closings, median sale price $835,000

Twelve homes closed in Sayville in the 30 days ending August 18, at a median sale price of $835,000. That compares with $750,000 in the prior 30 days and $680,000 in the same window last year. Ten of the twelve closed at or above their asking price. Meanwhile there are 18 homes on the market and 22 already under contract.

August 18, 2026 · John Tiburzi, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

The closing figures are the story this month. The median of $835,000 sits above both the prior window and last summer, and the median time on market was 17 days, against 14 in the prior window and 25 a year ago. Closings ran from $484,000 to $1,200,000, so the median is carrying a wide spread. With 12 sales in the window, and 9 in the one before it, these are small counts and one or two larger houses move the middle figure.

One thing that did not move up is price per square foot: the median was $415 in this window, compared with $531 in the prior 30 days and $476 a year ago. Read alongside the higher median sale price, that says the houses that closed were larger, not simply dearer per foot.

On the supply side, 18 homes are listed and 22 are under contract, which is more pending than available. The 30 day pace works out to 1.5 months of supply. Ten of the 18 listed are asking between $500,000 and $749,999, seven have been listed 30 days or more, and two have been on 90 days or more. Just one new listing came out this week, at $739,000.

If you are selling here, the asking prices that closed recently averaged 104.7 percent of ask. If you are buying, the choice is narrow at the moment, and the median annual taxes on what closed were $13,541, worth checking line by line on any house you look at.

Questions about Sayville

What is the median home price in Sayville right now?

For the 12 homes that closed in Sayville in the 30 days ending August 18, 2026, the median sale price was $835,000. Sales in that window ran from $484,000 to $1,200,000. In the prior 30 day window the median was $750,000, and in the same window in 2025 it was $680,000.

How many homes are for sale in Sayville?

As of August 18, 2026 there were 18 homes for sale in Sayville, with a median asking price of $739,500 and a range from $335,000 to $1,950,000. Sixteen are single family residences and two are stock cooperatives. The median number of bedrooms among them is three.

Are homes in Sayville selling above asking price?

Of the 12 Sayville homes that closed in the 30 days ending August 18, 2026, ten sold at or above their asking price, which is 83 percent. The average sale to ask ratio was 104.7 percent. In the prior 30 day window all nine closings were at or above asking, at an average of 106.3 percent.

How long do homes take to sell in Sayville?

The 12 Sayville homes that closed in the 30 days ending August 18, 2026 had a median of 17 days on market. That compares with 14 days in the prior 30 day window and 25 days in the same window last year. Among the 18 homes currently listed, the median days listed is 29, with seven listed 30 days or more and two listed 90 days or more.

Is Sayville a tight market for buyers this month?

As of August 18, 2026 there were 18 homes for sale in Sayville and 22 already under contract, with a median asking price of $789,000 on the pending group. At the current 30 day pace that is 1.5 months of supply. Only one new listing came on the market in the week of August 12 to 18, asking $739,000.

What are property taxes on homes selling in Sayville?

Among the 12 Sayville homes that closed in the 30 days ending August 18, 2026, the median annual taxes were $13,541. That compares with $12,583 for the nine closings in the prior 30 day window and $12,198 for the 19 closings in the same window last year. Taxes vary house by house, so check the figure on any specific property.

These are figures for one town over one 30 day window, drawn only from what the MLS recorded, and with 12 closings this window a single large or small sale can shift the medians.

Market figures for Sayville are from OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID, as of August 18, 2026. Counts and medians cover the listings the MLS recorded and are aggregates; no individual listing is described.