Sold

258 Bay Walk Fire Island Pines, NY 11782

$1,275,000

Listed at $1,800,000. Closed February 6, 2026.

Listing courtesy of David P. Sanders, Compass Greater NY LLC MLS #KEY829185

  • 5 beds
  • 4 baths
  • 2,300 sq ft
  • $554 per sq ft
  • 1974 built
Photograph of 258 Bay Walk

Only the front exterior photograph is shown on closed sales, in keeping with OneKey MLS rules.

About this home

Fire Island Pines. A Bayfront Original with Elevated Potential. Welcome to Clamalot, a bay-front classic with a name as unforgettable as its setting. Perched high on a dune and accessed by a private bridge from Bay Walk, this 5-bedroom, 3.5 bath beach house sits above the flood zone and offers panoramic views of the Great South Bay. Built in 1974 and held by the same family ever since, Clamalot is a true original, full of character, privacy, and possibility. From the lion’s head knocker to the hand-lettered nameplate on the gate, every detail hints at the home’s storied past and one-of-a-kind charm. Inside, a multi-level layout offers room to gather or retreat, with a full-floor primary suite and sliders opening to a private bayview balcony. Main living and dining areas connect to multi-tiered decks ideal for entertaining. Outside, enjoy a decked-in pool with a new liner, and an updated Navy-style bulkhead—ready for kayaks, paddle-boards, and sunset sails. While the home awaits your vision and updates, its foundation is rare: high elevation, water frontage, and a legacy of single ownership. Clam-a-Lot isn’t just a house—it’s a Fire Island original, ready for its next chapter.

Description supplied by the listing broker.

Features

  • First Floor Bedroom
  • First Floor Full Bath
  • Breakfast Bar
  • Cathedral Ceiling(s)
  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Double Vanity
  • Eat-in Kitchen
  • ENERGY STAR Qualified Door(s)
  • Entrance Foyer
  • High Ceilings
  • Natural Woodwork
  • Open Floorplan
  • Open Kitchen
  • Pantry

This listing

  1. February 6, 2026 Sold for $1,275,000
  2. August 2, 2025 Listed at $1,800,000

Location

258 Bay Walk, Fire Island Pines, NY 11782

Nearby recent sales