Team Tiburzi Real Estate

For Sale

121 Bayway Avenue Bay Shore, NY 11706

$1,200,000

Listed July 30, 2026

Listing courtesy of Emily LaRocca, Netter Real Estate Inc MLS #KEY1032680

  • 4 beds
  • 3 baths
  • 2,904 sq ft
  • $413 per sq ft
  • 2013 built
Photograph of 121 Bayway Avenue

About this home

Welcome to this exceptional 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath Colonial, fully renovated to offer a sophisticated blend of modern luxury, thoughtful design, and effortless living south of Montauk. Built in 2013, the home features radiant heat flooring throughout, including the oversized one-car garage, along with two gas fireplaces that bring warmth and character to the living spaces. The main level offers a beautifully designed layout with a bedroom, separate den and living room, and an impressive kitchen appointed with high-end appliances and finishes, including two ovens for effortless entertaining. Upstairs, the king-sized primary bedroom is a true retreat, complete with its own gas fireplace, a beautifully appointed full primary bathroom, and an exceptionally spacious custom closet offering abundant storage. Two additional bedrooms complete the second level, providing plenty of space for all. Outdoors, enjoy a natural gas BBQ setup ideal for summer entertaining, along with the added privacy of having no backyard neighbors. Every element of this home has been carefully considered, from its elevated finishes and generous room sizes to the comfort and functionality of its floor plan. Ideally situated south of Montauk, this stunning residence delivers exceptional quality, privacy, and a refined South Shore lifestyle.

Description supplied by the listing broker.

Features

  • First Floor Bedroom
  • Breakfast Bar
  • Cathedral Ceiling(s)
  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Chandelier
  • Eat-in Kitchen
  • High Ceilings
  • Kitchen Island
  • Open Floorplan
  • Open Kitchen
  • Pantry
  • Primary Bathroom
  • Quartz/Quartzite Counters
  • Recessed Lighting

This listing

  1. July 30, 2026 Listed at $1,200,000 2 days ago

Location

121 Bayway Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706

About Bay Shore

I have closed six sales in Bay Shore. They run from 456,000 on Kansas Avenue in August 2020 to 720,000 on Elayne Avenue in December 2024, with a median sold price of 565,000. The other four were 515,000 on Thompson Drive, 540,000 on Windsor Avenue, 590,000 on William Street and 680,000 on Millay Lane.

Figures are from John Tiburzi's own closed transactions, data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID, covering August 2020 to August 2026.

More on Bay Shore

Nearby homes for sale