Team Tiburzi Real Estate

For Sale

202 Captains Way Bay Shore, NY 11706

$1,500,000

Listed June 1, 2026

Listing courtesy of Jessica M. Bathija, Keller Williams Rty Gold Coast MLS #KEY1011815

  • 2 beds
  • 2 baths
  • 1,796 sq ft
  • $835 per sq ft
  • 1977 built
Photograph of 202 Captains Way

About this home

Welcome to Admiralty, a luxury gated community this beautifully appointed waterfront residence, where boating, private beach access, and resort-style living creates an exclusive coastal lifestyle.This beautifully appointed 2-bedroom residence showcases elegant imported flooring, soaring cathedral ceilings, and a breathtaking living room centered around a warm and inviting fireplace. The spacious gourmet kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, featuring premium stainless-steel appliances, a stylish bar area, and an open, sophisticated layout. The primary suite offers a private spa-like bathroom and with two walk-in closets, while additional features include a washer and dryer, ample storage, a spacious garage, and attic space. Step outside to your private patio, perfect for hosting family gatherings or enjoying peaceful outdoor living. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the deep-water marina with private dockage and direct access to the Great South Bay. Situated within a meticulously maintained 158-acre waterfront community, residents enjoy an unparalleled lifestyle with 24/7 gated security, a newly renovated clubhouse, fitness center with Pilates and other wellness classes, three tennis courts, a pickleball court, private gardens, kayaking, a private beach, and a resort-style swimming pool with lifeguards. Perfectly positioned across from Fire Island’s Kismet and Ocean Beach and just a short drive to the Hamptons, this rare offering delivers the ultimate blend of luxury, recreation, and waterfront elegance. It includes snow removal, grass mowing and outside maintenance.Conveniently located near public transportation and supermarkets for easy everyday living.Just minutes from Bay Shore, offering access to shopping, dining, waterfront parks,less than two miles from ferry terminals to fire island and only one hour from NYC via LIRR. Don't miss out. https://theadmiraltyhoa.org

Description supplied by the listing broker.

Features

  • First Floor Bedroom
  • First Floor Full Bath
  • Cathedral Ceiling(s)
  • Eat-in Kitchen
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Formal Dining
  • Granite Counters
  • Marble Counters
  • Pantry
  • Storage
  • Walk-In Closet(s)

This listing

  1. June 1, 2026 Listed at $1,500,000 5 days ago

Location

202 Captains Way, Bay Shore, NY 11706

About Bay Shore

I have closed six sales in Bay Shore. They run from 456,000 on Kansas Avenue in August 2020 to 720,000 on Elayne Avenue in December 2024, with a median sold price of 565,000. The other four were 515,000 on Thompson Drive, 540,000 on Windsor Avenue, 590,000 on William Street and 680,000 on Millay Lane.

Figures are from John Tiburzi's own closed transactions, data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID, covering August 2020 to August 2026.

More on Bay Shore

Nearby homes for sale