Equal Housing Opportunity NYS Housing and Anti-Discrimination Notice

Licensed Real Estate Broker 95 W Main St, Sayville, NY 11782 Office: (631) 567-0100

Thinking of selling? Ask John what your home is worth

at Signature Premier Properties

John Tiburzi on Sayville Market

Sayville Real Estate Market, October 2026

Sayville's median sale price fell to $715,000 in October 2026 from $865,000 in September, and sat close to the $722,500 median of October 2025.

October 31, 2026, updated · John Tiburzi, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

The drop came with a change in what sold rather than a softening in price. Median price per square foot rose to $471 from $468 in September and $437 a year earlier, while the median size of what closed fell to 1,429 square feet from 2,078.

Eight houses closed, down from eleven in September and eighteen a year earlier, and all eight went at or above asking at a median of 104.4 percent of list. Houses went to contract in a median of eight days, the shortest stretch in the past year and down from nineteen days in September and eighteen in October 2025.

The spread was tight. Six of the eight sales landed between $600,000 and $799,999, one came in between $500,000 and $599,999 and one between $800,000 and $899,999. Nothing closed below $500,000 or above $900,000, against three sales at $1,000,000 and over in October 2025. Eleven new listings came on, up from nine in September.

October 2026 against the last year

October 2026 Lowest Highest Where it ranks
Median sale price $715,000 $544,000 $865,000 12 of 16
Median days on market 8 days 8 days 28 days lowest of 16
Median price per square foot $471 $357 $517 4 of 16
Sold at or above asking 100% 25% 100% highest of 16
Closed sales 8 2 19 11 of 16
Sale price against asking 104.4% 98.6% 110.5% 5 of 16
Median size of what sold 1,429 sq ft 1,240 sq ft 2,220 sq ft 14 of 16

Ranked against the 16 months John Tiburzi holds for Sayville, not against the whole record.

Data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID as of October 2026.

Median sale price, month by month

Sayville, Jul 2025 to Oct 2026. Low $544,000, high $865,000.
MonthMedian sale price
Jul 2025 $750,000
Aug 2025 $712,500
Sep 2025 $726,250
Oct 2025 $722,500
Nov 2025 $748,500
Dec 2025 $777,500
Jan 2026 $670,000
Feb 2026 $772,500
Mar 2026 $544,000
Apr 2026 $723,000
May 2026 $840,000
Jun 2026 $690,000
Jul 2026 $825,000
Aug 2026 $845,000
Sep 2026 $865,000
Oct 2026 $715,000

Data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID as of October 2026.

What sold in Sayville, by price

8 closed sales in October 2026, against 18 in October 2025.
Price October 2026 Share October 2025
$300k to $400k 0 0% 1
$400k to $500k 0 0% 2
$500k to $600k 1 13% 1
$600k to $700k 3 38% 4
$700k to $800k the median is here 3 38% 3
$800k to $900k 1 13% 3
$900k to $1m 0 0% 1
$1m and above 0 0% 3

Data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID as of October 2026.

Questions about Sayville

What is a house in Sayville worth right now?

The median sale price in Sayville was $715,000 in October 2026, down from $865,000 in September 2026 and close to the $722,500 median of October 2025. Median price per square foot was $471, up from $468 the month before and $437 a year earlier.

How long does it take to sell a house in Sayville?

Houses that closed in Sayville in October 2026 went to contract in a median of eight days, the shortest stretch in the past year. That compares with nineteen days in September 2026 and eighteen days in October 2025.

Are houses selling over asking in Sayville?

All eight Sayville sales that closed in October 2026 went at or above asking, at a median of 104.4 percent of list price. In September 2026 ten of eleven sales closed at or above asking, and in October 2025 the share was 83.33 percent at a median of 102.87 percent of list.

What price range do most Sayville houses sell in?

Of the eight Sayville sales in October 2026, six closed between $600,000 and $799,999, one between $500,000 and $599,999 and one between $800,000 and $899,999. No sale closed below $500,000 or at $900,000 and over.

Why did Sayville's median price drop if the market is still competitive?

Median sale price in Sayville fell from $865,000 in September 2026 to $715,000 in October, but median price per square foot rose to $471 from $468. Median square footage of the closings fell from 2,078 to 1,429, so smaller houses made up the month.

How many houses sold in Sayville in October 2026?

Eight closed sales were recorded in Sayville in October 2026, down from eleven in September 2026 and eighteen in October 2025. Eleven new listings came on the market during the month, against nine in September.

Are million dollar houses selling in Sayville?

No Sayville sale closed at $900,000 or above in October 2026. A year earlier, in October 2025, three sales closed at $1,000,000 and over and one between $900,000 and $999,999.

Is Sayville a fast market?

In October 2026 the median time to contract in Sayville was eight days and every one of the eight closings went at or above asking. Both September 2026 and October 2025 ran longer, at nineteen and eighteen median days respectively.

These are medians across eight closings, so they describe the month in aggregate and not the condition, location or finish of any one house.

Data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID as of October 2026.

Get market updates from John

John will send occasional updates. You can stop them any time.

Privacy

John Tiburzi Talk to John